Home » TNFD Dances » Dance Info Pages » Turkey » Ali Paşa

Ali Paşa – Turkey [Bora Özkök]

Links:
Pronunciation:AH-lee PA-sha
Translation:General Ali
Region:Western (song from East)
Aliases:Pasha
Choreographed:Bora Özkök
Year:1971
Form:Open Circle or Short Lines (closed circle in Fort Collins)
Skill:Easy
Energy:Moderate
Hand Hold:W-Pinkie
Leads to:Right w/ R foot
Meter:5/4; QQQS
Song:Ali Paşa Ağıdı (Ali Pasha Lament)
* also known by the 1st line:
Arpa Ektim Biçemedim (I Sowed Barley but Couldn’t Reap)
Artists:Modern Folk Üçlüsü (1970, 45 rpm & 40 Yıl Sonra, 1974)
James Durst, My Country Is the World, 1997
Date Taught:
Teacher:
Posted:November 16, 2023
Updated:November 19, 2023

This simple, catchy dance is not without controversy. Firstly, although it is most definitely a dance choreographed by a Turkish person to an old Turkish folk song, it is clearly only a dance that an international folk dance group could truly love and not one you would find anyone in the country of Türkiye actually dancing. As Ron Houston comments in Folk Dance Problem Solver 1987-4: “A true folk dancer’s dance, Ali Paşa has figures also found in Serbian, Mexican, Greek, and Israeli folk dances.” [Folk]lore has it that Bora later regretted concocting the dance and eschewed it. I don’t find it much different from other dances specially crafted for the international folk dance community. It has a catchy tune and steps and movements that mimic the melody. If we start being concerned over authenticity of dances we do for recreational international folk dancing, we are going to have a thin repertoire, although I do love the living dances with a basic step choreography that work for family of tunes rather than a specific one (Čoček, Kalamatianós, Pogonishte, etc.)

The second controversy arises in our Fort Collins group. There is a “Fort Collins way” to do the dance that has been around for over fifty years. I did okay as a follower; none the wiser. However, transitioning from follower to leader and learning the details of many dances over COVID-19 shutdown, I have discovered that I am now a foreigner in our village for several dances. I learned the dance from YouTube videos and sites like Folk Dance Musings. The Fort Collins village does it differently, but I haven’t figured out just how. I thought it was a matter of swapping the order of two figures, Runs (Bir) with Grapevines (İki), but the sequence doesn’t seem to be the issue. My latest theory is that it’s when the dance starts and with which figure, so it’s a matter of dance-music alignment.

The Song

The song “Ali Paşa Ağıdı” (Ali Pasha Lament”), also know by the first line of the song, Arpa Ektim Biçemedim (I Sowed Barley but Couldn’t Reap), tells the triumphant and tragic tale of General Ali, of which there are many in history. Don Buskirk of Folkdance Footnotes concludes (and the comments from Doğan Canku below concur) this “General Ali” was of the Ottoman Empire era, appointed in 1907 to be the Governor of the Van region of far east Anatolia (Armenian, Assyrian, Kurdish areas now part of Turkey). He was effective in quashing Armenian resistance in the area, but his “peacemaking” (through repression) was rewarded with assassination by Armenians not keen on subjugation. Read more details of the history below and on Don’s site. Don has a couple different takes on lyrics translations. I provide the common lyrics below from The Society of Folk Dance Historians (SFDH). Lyrics on Folk Dance Musings add a chorus, but a raw Google translation is very strange: /Bride with gold and sequins, Let me give you liras. When you have this beauty, Let me line up five-a-side./

Song Background From Modern Folk Üçlüsü Founder Doğan Canku

Modern Folk Trio: Music group founded by Doğan Canku, Ahmet Kurtaran and Selami Karaibrahimgil in 1969 and managed by Hıncal Uluç. The group created most of the old folk songs they sang by using the archives of Doğan Canku’s father, who was a music researcher. We tried to perform the Ali Pasha Lament, a 400-year-old lament from the Van region, from the hall of our Music House.

The story of the Turk is briefly as follows.

During the period when Ali Pasha was the Governor of Van, the Armenian rebellion intensified. Armenian gangs raided villages and massacred the Muslim people, and the people were unable to cultivate their fields due to fear of the gangs. Pasha, who embarked on a great struggle against the Armenian Komitaists, achieved great success. He prevents possible massacres by raiding the weapons warehouses of the Committee members and seizing thousands of weapons and ammunition.

Since Ali Pasha’s successes were not liked by the European States, he was dismissed on October 20, 1908, as a result of the pressure they put on the Istanbul Government. Even though the people of Van, who loved Ali Pasha very much, sent telegrams to Istanbul and asked for his reinstatement, the situation does not change. Ali Pasha wants to go to Batumi via Erzurum-Revan and reach his family in Istanbul by sea. Just as he was about to board the ship in Batumi, he was shot and martyred by the Armenian Komitacıs who set up an ambush. The news of Ali Pasha’s martyrdom reached Van in a short time. And the people of Van are very saddened by this news. This lament takes its place in our culture as a product of the people’s love and respect for their former governor.

Google translation of YouTube description for Doğan Canku – Doğu Ekin & Kemal Kaya – Ali Paşa Ağıdı

Dance-Music Sequence Alignment

The recording of “Ali Paşa Ağıdı” as performed by Modern Folk Üçlüsü has three parts, and the choreographed dance follows suit. The core of the song is even simpler. There is an A part and a B part. Each part is a 4-bar melody phrase, always repeated twice, for a total of 8 bars per part. That means there are only 8 unique bars of music in the entire song, so it’s hard to get too carried away about dance alignment to the music! I call the A part the verse and the B part the chorus, but it’s not really a chorus, because the words are different each time through. Both parts A & B introduce new sung verses while a B’ (B-prime) instrumental is always added by Modern Folk Üçlüsü after B is sung. In the B’ part, the beauty of the three-part vocal harmony is substituted with a banjo plucking out the melody, and this stark contrast might lead you to believe this is some new melody and not just a repeat of B. I’m certain they added a consistent B’ part just so that folk dancers could use the recording 😉. There is a 16-bar intro, and you could say there is an A’, because the intro is A played on guitar rather than sung, then it is followed by B on banjo, so that’s A’+B’, if you care about that level of detail, but there is no new melody, bridge, or riff to be found there.

Standard Alignment prescribed by Bora Özkök:
(The dance sequence can also be done by leader call.)

16 bar A'+B' intro (Bop in place.)
 - I like the idea of starting the dance with 3-Üç (Brushes) when B' starts, rather than standing around 8 more bars waiting it out, but most (all?) groups in YouTube videos wait and bop in place.

8 bars A  verse singing:        1-Bir: Runs
8 bars B  chorus, singing:      2-İki: Grapevines
8 bars B' chorus, instrumental: 3-Üç:  Brushes
repeat, starting with Runs on singing of next verse...
- The final 8 bar phrase is a repeat of the last B singing chorus (4x through), which falls on dance Part 3: Brushes.

Ali Paşa Ağıdı Lyrics

Lyrics used by Modern Folk Üçlüsü

// Arpa ektim, biçlemedim. Bir düs gördüm, seçemedim. //
// Alışmışım soğuk suya; ıssığ sular içemedim. //

// Üç atım var, biri binek. Arkadaşlar kalkın gidek. //
// Ali Paşayı vurdular. Yavrusuna haber verek. //

// Paşa giyer iki kürkü, biri samur biri tilki. //
// Ali Paşayı vurdular. Harab oldu Van'ın nurdu. //

// Karavanaya vurdular, yüzbaşılar darıldılar. //
//// Darılmayın yüzbaşılar, Ali Paşayı vurdular. ////
I planted barley, never harvested it. I had a dream, didn't recognize it.
I am used to cold waters; I do not drink hot water.

I have three horses, one very good one. Come on friends, let's get up and go.
General Ali has been shot. Let's take the news to his kin.

The General wears two fur coats, one is mink, the other is fox.
General Ali has been hit. The wonder of the town of Van* is gone.

When he asked to eat in the mess hall, the captains got mad after all.
You need not get mad, oh captains, General Ali has been shot.

*Van: a town in east Anatolia
The Society of Folk Dance Historians (SFDH)

Teaching & Dancing Examples

Some newer videos introduce an arm swing in Part 3, and even a pre-swing setting before the arm swing. See Henry & Sue Ellen’s video.

Karen Faust
Teaching: Green Valley Folk Dance Club, Arizona
Henry & Sue Ellen: Arm swings added on Part 3 (bad video frame rate)
Dunav: Arm swings added on Part 3

Music for Normal Dance Sequence

Original IFD version: Modern Folk Üçlüsü, 1970 single packaged on 1974 album, 40 Yıl Sonra
Modern Folk Üçlüsü Founder Doğan Canku & Friends. This is the video with the background info on the song quoted above.
American folk version: James Durst, 1997. Same music pattern as Modern Folk Üçlüsü.
Modern Folk Üçlüsü live TV broadcast.

Click for More Videos From Modern Folk Üçlüsü

Music: Dancing (with non-standard sequence) & Listening

Operatic version by Zafer Erdaş
Hasan Cihat Örter – Electric bass
Ruhi Su – Classic Turkish folk singing
Grup Orhun – Doesn’t get to the song until 1:09, but it’s good.
Tolga Çandar – Starts right up.
Haluk Tolga İlhan – The least danceable.